Monsoon
Wedding --- Viewing Guide and Discussion Questions
Dr. Michael Wutz, Weber State University |
General:
Monsoon Wedding is a film that self-consciously fuses the conventions of
Hollywood with Bollywood films (see below). Unlike the classical single- or
dual-star Hollywood film, Monsoon Wedding paints on a large canvas,
with lots of characters (sometimes introduced only by their nick names, and
then only in passing) on the screen, similar to a Brueghel painting. This
epic breadth presents difficulties to the viewer. At one point, Hemant, the
bicultural groom flown in from Houston, observes, "I don't even know who is
who half of the time," which may well echo the viewers' experience as well.
While advance knowledge is almost always useful for a film screening, it is
particularly so for this one: read carefully through a summary to
familiarize yourself in advance with the characters. That will help you not
lose your bearings too quickly and, once you've gotten the hang of it, stay
focused without trying to workout who is who. Naturally as well, this film
benefits from repeat viewings, as will your grasp of it.
(1) Henna and Cellphones
Monsoon Wedding shows an India—a land with an old history and ancient
cultures—in the throes of transition. Age-old rituals and traditions
coexist, not always peacefully, with cell phones and wrist calculators,
television talk shows and cooking shows, a burgeoning film industry and
daily stock market quotes. Locate some of the major effects of western
acculturation and discuss their significance in the film. How do the various
generations deal with the dialogue of the East and the West, the Old and the
New?
(2) Gender, Identity, and Love
The parallel love stories of Aditi and
Hemant and Alice and Dubey are of course at the narrative center of
Monsoon Wedding. Try to pay attention how the film engineers these
parallel relationships—significantly, of different classes—and see how the
film both supports and redefines traditional assumptions about gender and
class. What are Hemant and Dubey's expectations about women and how do they
correct these assumptions? Conversely, how do brides and mothers and fathers
expect their grooms and sons to behave?
(3) Money and Class
Related to expectations about gender
and identity (question #2), Monsoon Wedding also stages the financial
expectations that come with a certain class. If Lalit frets about being able
to pay for a wedding that behooves his social and cultural origins (from
Punjab)—even to the point of getting a coronary—Dubey and Alice's
working-class origins call for a very different kind of wedding. Identify
the moments in the film when money in the widest sense is at issue. How do
Lalit (and his friends) and Dubey (and his fellow workers) make a living?
How do other characters in the film support themselves (and others)? To what
degree (if any) is capital still tied to class, and how has it become a
free-floating commodity on the world market?
(4) The Skeleton in the Closet—Child Sexual Abuse
Early critics of Monsoon
Wedding lamented that the sudden exposure of Tej Uncle's child sexual
abuse of, first, Aditi's cousin Ria, then the ten-year-old Aliya breaks with
the celebratory and delirious energy of the film, and is furthermore
introduced too late in the story. Yet, even during a first viewing of the
film, intimations of this abuse (together with other dark undertones) are
implanted in the film and seem to function, not as a sudden interruption of
a joyous occasion, but as the parallel dark underbelly of healthy (and not
just sexual) relationships. They also explain Ria's hesitation about
relationships, her advice to Aditi, and her comments about kissing, among
others. Trace the major allusions to this buildup of Ria's accusation and
discuss why Nair made it coincide with the night before the actual wedding.
Why does Ria not reveal it earlier? What is at stake for all the major
characters in the film?
(5) Delirious, Delicious Delhi
Early in Monsoon Wedding
you notice that, spliced into the emerging stories of the film are
impressions and images of Delhi, both the Old and the New. Easily
dismissible as filler to capture, in passing, the location of the film,
these images also serve as important visual commentary on plot development,
changing mood, and other complications. Identify these shots (often from a
driving car) of Delhi and discuss how they enhance the filmic power of this
film. Why the association of the weddings with the monsoon season?
(6) Total Engagement
Nair once said, "I have to have
that feeling of total engagement when I am filming, and to feel totally
engaged, everything has to feel correct: the décor,
the lighting, the way we move the camera, the lens. The balance, the
rightness of things, is very important. It's an unbelievable privilege to be
a director." Another way of saying this would be to say that Nair wants to
maximize the medium she is working with—that is, film—to the fullest
possible effect. Identify moments in Monsoon Wedding that demonstrate
such balanced fullness. What do such moments achieve?
(7) Hollywood meets Bollywood
Monsoon Wedding is a film
that self-consciously fuses the conventions of Hollywood with Bollywood
films. As such it is also a film that plays to US and Indian audiences (and
Nair has repeatedly noted how pleased she was that the film was well
received in India). Briefly research or recap some of the conventions of
Bollywood and Hollywood feature films and see how Monsoon Wedding
merges those two genres. What might this cinematic hybrid, perhaps, want to
say on the level of filmic form. To have a bigger market share, perhaps, but
what else? — Think of the various unions going on in the film, the various
languages, the various cultures. Why might this fusion of conventions and
genre expectations be important?