Assignment 2: Proposing Solutions, English 1010 |
Assignment:
Write an essay proposing a solution to a problem. Choose a problem faced by a community or group (to which you may or may not belong), and address your proposal to the members of the group or, alternately, to an outsider who might help solve the problem. Keep in mind that a proposal is essentially a call to action. That is, you not only want to convince your readers that the problem at hand is real and urgent and has an immediate impact on their lives; you also want to persuade them to endorse and put into effect your proposed solution to the problem. The better you can identify your readers' knowledge and/or ignorance of the problem, and the better you can relate the problem to their personal lives, the more likely you are going to persuade them of the validity of your concern and thus enlist their cooperation.An effective proposal typically has the following features:
(1) A Clearly Defined Problem. A well-defined problem frequently
provides the grounds for your proposed solution to the problem. Therefore, you
will not only need to define the problem, but also show its existence and its
seriousness, particularly in relation to your target group. In addition, you may
also have to analyze the history of the problem, its causes and consequences,
and perhaps show the (failure of) past efforts in dealing with it.
(2) A Proposed Solution. After you have sketched out your problem,
you need to advance and argue for a particular solution to the problem. This
solution usually comprises the thesis of your proposal. (Note that your paper
has, therefore, an almost natural, built-in structure: from the presentation of
the problem to the proposition and deployment of your solution.)
(3) A Convincing Argument. Since you want to convince your audience
that your proposal is the best possible one, you need to demonstrate the
effectiveness, the feasibility, and the overall quality of your proposal, its
superiority to or advantage over other proposals, if you will. That means that
you will have to show that your proposal can achieve the desired result, that it
can reasonably be put into practice (financially, technologically,
environmentally, etc.), and that it can stand against anticipated counter
arguments.
(4) A Reasonable Tone. Since you want to establish a dialogue and
appeal to your audience's reason, you need to adopt a measured and balanced tone
in your presentation. Such an "objective" tone lends you rhetorical
authority and credibility, more so than frantically trying to rouse your
readers' emotions. Do not come across as belligerent or feisty.
Length: 3-5 typed, double-spaced pages.
Due Dates:
Fri 6 Oct, First Draft. While I will not
collect your first draft on that day, have it available for improvement
during our revision workshop and for general inspection.
As always, please bring a second copy.
Mon 9 Oct, No class in lieu of additional office hours,
10:00-11:30. Sign-up required.
Wed 11 Oct, In class. Second Draft (with notebook and copy of
first/previous draft[s])
PLEASE NOTE: As with your first essay, make sure that you have stapled the materials for this assignment so that your final/second draft is on top and clearly identified as such, followed by your earlier draft(s) and your notebook underneath.
Purpose and Goals: This assignment should help you
Evaluation: Your final draft will be evaluated primarily on the basis of the following criteria:
Sincere Tips
Dr. Michael Wutz